summarize the main legal points being made U.S attorney David Weiss in November
2022 allowed the statute of limitations
to expire even though Hunter Biden’s
attorney had already agreed to extend
the statute on the 2014 and 2015 charges
which charges included an attempt to
evade or defeat taxes and the fraud and
false statements related to the million
dollars that barisma paid to Hunter
Biden while his father was vice
president
during a recent transcribed interview
with the committee FBI officials from
the Baltimore Field office refused to
answer questions about the expired 2014
and 2015 tax charges because they were
allegedly part of a quote ongoing
investigation
are the tax charges related to these
years in fact part of an ongoing
investigation
I have no familiarity with the details
of this particular investigation so you
don’t know one way or the other that’s
right I left so how are charges for
which the statute of limitations have
already expired part of an ongoing
investigation
again I I don’t know anything about this
case so why would so why would charges
that have already expired because of the
statute of limit of limitations be part
of an ongoing investigation in a in a
hype dancer in the hypothetical because
I don’t know the facts often charges
from previous times are used as part of
an ongoing investigation to inform
information about intent about patterns
and or other investigations
so are there other investigations into
hutter Biden where this information may
become relevant
I think it’s a matter of public record
that there are is a tax investigation of
Mr Hunter Biden with respect to other
years beyond the 2014 and 2015.
beyond the ones that are um uh where
this that you’re referring to I think Mr
Garland Weiss has already said that and
and during The Plea proceed okay Mr
Garland is it standard operating
procedure in your Department of Justice
for prosecutors to allow the statute of
limitations to expire on very serious
crimes when the potential debt defendant
has already agreed to an extension
so there as I said before there’s no
standard operating procedure here this
is maybe there should be well this is an
oversight hearing maybe there should be
maybe you should adopt standard
operating procedures to avoid this kind
of a circumstance would you agree no
okay because
you’ve answered my question thank you
according to one of the IRS
whistleblowers
quote the purposeful exclusion of the
2014 and 2015 tax years sanitized
the most substantive criminal conduct
and concealed material facts end quote
how can Americans trusted investigation
run by a special counsel who by allowing
the statute of limitations to expire
irreversibly quote sanitized the most
substantive criminal conduct and
concealed material facts the prosecuring
question is a experienced veteran career
prosecutor Who was appointed by we have
no reason to trust him I president Trump
okay how much in terms of taxes would
Hunter Biden have owed on the one
million dollars he was paid by barisma
well as you can imagine since I don’t
know anything about the facts of the
case I can’t answer probably about four
hundred thousand dollars isn’t that
right I mean you could do the math you
know the tax code
I don’t know anything about the facts of
this case so I’m not able to do the math
to apply it and by failing to pay the
taxes on those ill-gotten gains what
would the tip the penalty have been
for example if it was someone who didn’t
have the last name of Biden or a d
behind their name I’m sorry these are
all questions you’ll have to direct to
Mr Weiss in a Mr Weiss will address in
in his final by allowing the statute of
limitations to lapse did Mr Weiss
effectively gift the tax money hudder
Biden owed for the 2014 and 2015 tax
years to Mr Biden to say again the
decisions about whether in this area and
whether these allegations are correct or
ones that Mr Weiss will be able to
answer Mr Garland what one of the things
you’ve done over and repeat it over and
over and over again is that to point out
that Mr Weiss was appointed as U.S
attorney by President Trump as though
that somehow inoculates him from
criticism by us is that really how this
game is played that if someone is
appointed by a republican then they’re
supposed to be on the Republican team or
the if they’re appointed by a Democrat
they’re on the Democrat team you are
appointed by Mr Biden weren’t you are
you on the Democrats let me just be
clear the point of he’s a that he was
appointed by Republican counteracts the
claim that he this was a partisan
decision to benefit Democrats he
remained as as a member of the
Department of Justice Mr chairman Mr
chairman I’m the general lady has
expired the uh gentleman from Maryland
is recognized again for unanimous
consent request thank you Mr chairman I
want to offer into evidence the
testimony or
segments of the testimony of Thomas
sobasinski dated September 7th uh it was
taken here and before this committee
goes to the deconfliction issue with
respect to Hunter Biden’s security
detail and the search warrant uh not
objection executors thank you
sure now recognize the gentleman from
California
Mr attorney general do you believe
Christopher Wray is a competent director
of the FBI
I think Mr Ray as a person of the
highest Integrity for whom I have great
admiration who has extraordinary
experience uh both as well you certainly
don’t
think sir I am sure that he would not
are you aware that director Ray a couple
months ago in sworn testimony implicated
you in a sweeping abuse of power
I doubt he would characterize whatever
you uh whatever he said in that way well
he testified
board memo that you issued
October 4th of 2021 uh in which you
mobilized federal law enforcement Powers
against American parents now of course
you didn’t put it quite like that
instead you found a pretext which is
stated right here in the first line of
the memo in recent months there has been
a disturbing spike in harassment
intimidation and threats of violence
against School administrators board
members teachers and staff what was your
basis for making that claim I will say
again as I’ve testified numerous times
in response to exactly the same question
that I I saw numerous reports in the
Press of violence and threats you saw
reports in the press and so you decided
to instigate a nationwide law
enforcement initiative if I may be
permitted to answer the question please
numerous reports in the media of
violence and threats of violence against
School Personnel of all kinds did you
consult with the FBI director we
received a letter from the National
Association of school boards reporting
yes that ladder contained anecdotes it
didn’t contain data of an increase did
you yes or no consult with the FBI
director before issuing the memo I don’t
believe I spoke with the FBI director no
why not why wouldn’t you consult with
the FBI director because the purpose of
the memo as is very clear from the memo
is to ask the FBI to assess the
situation to hold meetings and to
determine whether the Mr attorney
general you started with a conclusion
that there was an increase in threats
now if you had bothered to consult with
the FBI director here’s what he would
have said this is from his sworn
testimony that he was not aware of any
such evidence so my question to you sir
sitting here today is can you
substantiate your claim that there was
an increase of course there will always
be criminal sporadic criminal activity
in all quarters of society but your
claim was there was an increase can you
substantiate that sitting here today I
can substantiate that by the reports and
the Press of violence and threats of
violence and by the letter sent by
Representatives that’s a no you’re
giving us anecdotes I’m asking you if
you had data you all said in your memo
that you were
your compartments Authority resources to
discourage these threats identify them
when they occur and prosecute them when
appropriate were there any such
prosecutions the emphasis should be
there on when appropriate and there were
no such prosecutions and that’s good
news not bad news there were no
prosecutions and in fact director Ray
said there were no arrests there were no
charges so you have no data to show us
that there was any increase you didn’t
even bother to consult with the FBI
director and then there were no
resulting prosecutions even though you
said that they were coming so I have to
ask you now in retrospect was there a
compelling law enforcement justification
for the memo
I think you’re mischaracterizing the
memo the question the purpose of the
memo was to hold meetings to open lines
of communication with States so is that
a no yes or no was there a compelling
law enforcement justification for them I
believe there was a reason to ask for
those contacts to be made with state and
local law enforcement well the FBI
director disagrees with you
with the FBI director said look at it
right here
when asked do you have any reason to
dispute the conclusion that there was no
Nationwide law enforcement justification
he said he didn’t
either he didn’t see the reports or he
didn’t see the Nationals this is a
transcript I’ve sent you this transcript
Mr attorney general so my question is
this will you retract the memo and by
that I mean issue a formal document to
the effect that it is no longer
operative I will not because there was
absolutely nothing wrong with the memo
as I have testified several times
already even though your own FBI
director says there was no justification
for it you will not retract it
the memo is mine it’s my decision
whether it’s necessary to make
assessments like this and I asked the
bureau to make these assessments and the
other are you familiar with the concept
of a chilling effect I’m sorry are you
familiar with the concept of a chilling
effect I’m very familiar and that’s the
very reason why would you define a
chilling effect as it relates to First
Amendment the very reason why the second
sentence of the memo please tell me what
you’d consider to be the definition of a
chilling effect
that memo has no chilling effect I
didn’t ask you your opinion on whether
the memo has one I ask you what is a
chilling I’m telling you that the second
sentence of that makes clear I’ve read
the full memo I’m asking you what do you
define a chilling effect as
a chilling effect is when
um people’s exercise of First Amendment
rights are chilled by coercive activity
by the government which did not occur so
here we’re dealing with moms Mr chairman
you and I point of order with respect to
the time point of order that the
gentleman’s time has expired but it was
a pretty darn important question when
the Attorney General of the United
States can’t Define what a chilling
effect is so I thought it would let it
go a few seconds the uh the Attorney
General did Define what a chilling
effect is and said it didn’t occur here
I don’t think he’d defined it he just he
just dismissed it uh the gentleman’s
time has expired I thought it was a very
important five minutes we now recognize
the gentlelady from Florida for five
minutes
[Music]
music music
[Music]
[Music]
thank you
[Music]
recording studio
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
recording studio
[Music]
tonight
[Music]
[Music]
magic inside
[Music]
foreign
poll found that 37 of Americans have a
positive view of the FBI
and that’s from an NBC poll I wouldn’t
exactly call that right media propaganda
and I think I know why
here’s what the American people know and
believe about the FBI today sir
if you are a trump you will be
prosecuted if you are a Biden you’ll be
protected
and the American people that I represent
are sick and tired of this double
standard
seems like every single hearing that we
have in this room we talk about the
two-tiered justice system of bindio
binds doj and the FBI and as we were
talking earlier here we are again
president Trump endured an unprecedented
raid at his home in Mar-A-Lago
President Biden’s home however was
respectfully browsed
president Trump is facing up to 400
years in federal prison for allegedly
being in possession of classified
documents he obtained as the
commander-in-chief of these United
States of America and meanwhile
President Biden is facing no charges for
the classified documents he had held at
his time as a senator and a vice
president not the president of these
United States of America and last I
checked he had no legal authority to
declassify those documents
assuming president Trump was in
possession of said classified documents
with those documents be more secure
surrounded by secret service at
Mar-A-Lago or in a box in a garage
behind your Corvette
no they answer that question
for you sir
what can you tell us about the status of
the FBI’s investigation of President
Biden’s classified documents found next
to his Corvette in Delaware and those
found at the Penn Biden Center do we
have an update on that sir
what I can tell you is that there is an
ongoing special counsel investigation
led by Mr Robert Herr and we have FBI
agents uh affiliated with it working on
it working very actively and
aggressively with him on that case
I obviously disagree with your
description of the two standards in my
view we at least under my watch we have
one standard
and that is we’re going to pursue the
facts wherever they lead no matter who
likes it and I add that last part
because especially in sensitive
investigations almost by definition
somebody’s not going to like it so I I
understand that that’s actually why I
lived with the sentiment of the American
people Anderson
I do want to finish this so so I want
everybody to talk about this dichotomy
that we have seen I I get your point sir
but that’s just not what we see as the
public As We the People
What are some of the rituals from egypt of death. Not for he dead, but the ritual of death and resurrection
In November 2022, U.S. Attorney David Weiss made several key legal points during a congressional hearing:
1. Statute of Limitations: Weiss allowed the statute of limitations to expire on certain charges against Hunter Biden, despite Hunter Biden’s attorney agreeing to extend the statute for the 2014 and 2015 charges. These charges included attempts to evade or defeat taxes and fraud and false statements related to the million dollars that Burisma paid to Hunter Biden while his father was vice president.
2. FBI Refusal to Answer: During a transcribed interview with the committee, FBI officials from the Baltimore Field Office refused to answer questions about the expired 2014 and 2015 tax charges, citing an ongoing investigation.
3. Use of Previous Charges: Weiss explained that charges from previous years can be used as part of an ongoing investigation to gather information about intent, patterns, or other investigations.
4. Other Investigations: It was mentioned that there is a tax investigation into Hunter Biden for years beyond 2014 and 2015.
5. Appointment by President Trump: Weiss pointed out that he was appointed by President Trump to counter claims of partisanship in his decisions.
6. Chilling Effect and Memo: There was a discussion about the memo Weiss issued concerning threats and harassment against school personnel. Critics questioned the justification for the memo and suggested it could have a chilling effect on free speech.
7. Lack of Prosecutions: Weiss noted that there were no prosecutions or arrests related to the memo, emphasizing that prosecutions would only occur when appropriate.
8. Double Standards: Some members of the committee criticized what they saw as a double standard, with President Trump facing investigations and President Biden seemingly not facing similar scrutiny.
9. Ongoing Special Counsel Investigation: Weiss mentioned that there is an ongoing special counsel investigation led by Robert Herr into President Biden’s classified documents, with FBI agents actively working on the case.
10. Pursuit of Facts: Weiss emphasized that his approach is to pursue the facts regardless of who may or may not like the outcome, with the goal of maintaining one standard for investigations.
Overall, the hearing involved a discussion of various legal and investigatory issues, including the handling of charges, ongoing investigations, and perceptions of partisanship within the justice system.
In ancient Egypt, death and resurrection were central themes in their religious beliefs and rituals, particularly concerning the afterlife. Here are some key rituals and beliefs related to death and resurrection in ancient Egypt:
1. **Mummification**: The process of mummification was central to the belief in resurrection. Egyptians believed that preserving the body was essential for the soul’s journey to the afterlife. The process involved removing organs, drying the body, and wrapping it in linen bandages.
2. **Opening of the Mouth Ceremony**: This ritual was performed to ensure that the deceased could eat, drink, and breathe in the afterlife. It involved a priest using special tools to touch the mummy’s mouth and eyes while reciting prayers.
3. **Funerary Offerings**: The living would provide offerings of food, water, and other items to sustain the deceased in the afterlife. These offerings were placed in tombs and inscribed with prayers to ensure the well-being of the deceased.
4. **Book of the Dead**: This was a collection of spells and prayers written on papyrus or tomb walls. It was meant to guide the deceased through the dangers of the afterlife and assist them in reaching the final judgment.
5. **Osiris Myth**: The story of Osiris, the god of the afterlife and resurrection, was central to Egyptian mythology. Osiris was killed by his brother Seth but was later resurrected by his wife Isis. This myth symbolized the hope for resurrection for all Egyptians.
6. **Burial Tombs**: Egyptians built elaborate tombs, such as the pyramids, to serve as the final resting place for the deceased. These tombs were filled with items the deceased might need in the afterlife.
7. **The Weighing of the Heart**: In the Hall of Ma’at, the heart of the deceased was weighed against the feather of Ma’at (the goddess of truth and justice) in the presence of Osiris. If the heart was lighter than the feather, the deceased was deemed worthy of resurrection and granted access to the afterlife. If not, the heart was devoured by a monster, and the soul would face oblivion.
8. **Rebirth with Ra**: In the afterlife, the deceased’s soul was believed to join the sun god Ra on his daily journey across the sky. This journey symbolized rebirth and the eternal cycle of life.
9. **Offerings to the Sun God**: Daily offerings, including prayers and rituals, were made to Ra to ensure the continued journey of the sun and the renewal of life.
10. **Annual Festivals**: Egyptians celebrated various festivals and rituals throughout the year to honor the dead and ensure their continued existence in the afterlife. These festivals often included feasting, music, and offerings to the gods.
These rituals and beliefs demonstrate the profound importance of death and resurrection in ancient Egyptian culture. The Egyptians believed that death was not the end but a transition to a new and eternal existence in the afterlife, where they could be reunited with their loved ones and the gods.
I think this ritaul practice was symbolic. Perhaps laying in a coffin or box for three days, emerging and being ‘reborn’
The concept of death and rebirth was indeed symbolically important in various ancient cultures, and rituals involving a period of symbolic death and rebirth were not exclusive to Egypt. While the specific practice you mentioned, involving laying in a coffin or box for three days, may not have been a common or documented ritual in ancient Egypt, it bears similarities to broader themes of resurrection and renewal found in many ancient religions and mythologies.
1. **Osiris Myth**: As mentioned earlier, the myth of Osiris’s death and resurrection was a central theme in Egyptian mythology. Osiris, after being killed by his brother Seth, was later resurrected by his wife Isis. This myth symbolized the cyclical nature of life, death, and rebirth, which was a fundamental belief in ancient Egyptian religion.
2. **Symbolism of Coffins**: Coffins, sarcophagi, and burial chambers were often intricately decorated with religious symbols and inscriptions. These symbols and the act of placing the deceased inside the coffin can be seen as a representation of the deceased’s journey from the earthly realm to the afterlife, symbolizing a form of rebirth.
3. **Initiation Rituals**: In some mystery cults and initiation ceremonies of ancient Egypt and other civilizations, individuals might undergo symbolic death and rebirth experiences to mark their transition into a new spiritual state. These rituals often involved confinement, darkness, and a subsequent emergence to represent transformation and renewal.
4. **Solar Symbolism**: The rising sun was a powerful symbol of renewal and rebirth in many ancient cultures, including Egypt. The daily journey of the sun across the sky was associated with the cycle of life, and the concept of being reborn with the sun was prevalent in their religious beliefs.
It’s important to note that while specific rituals and practices may vary, the overarching theme of death and rebirth was a common thread in the spiritual and mythological beliefs of many ancient civilizations. These rituals were intended to convey the idea of transition, transformation, and the hope for a renewed existence in the afterlife or in a higher state of being.
Yes, let’s focus on Initiation Rituals:
Initiation rituals were significant in various ancient cultures and often involved symbolic experiences of death and rebirth. These rituals were designed to mark a person’s transition into a new phase of life, such as adulthood or membership in a particular religious or mystical group. Here are some examples of initiation rituals and their symbolic significance:
1. **Ancient Egyptian Mysteries**: In ancient Egypt, there were mystery cults like those of Osiris and Isis. Initiates underwent rituals that symbolized death, typically involving a period of seclusion or darkness, followed by an emergence or revelation. This symbolized the idea of spiritual awakening and the hope for a renewed and enlightened existence.
2. **Eleusinian Mysteries (Ancient Greece)**: The Eleusinian Mysteries were among the most famous initiation rituals in ancient Greece. These mysteries were dedicated to Demeter and Persephone and centered around the belief in the cycle of life, death, and rebirth. Initiates participated in ceremonies that were believed to reveal profound insights about the afterlife and the continuity of the soul.
3. **Mystery Cults of Mithras (Roman Empire)**: The initiation into the Mithraic cult involved several degrees of initiation, each with its own rituals and symbolism. The most famous depiction shows Mithras slaying a bull, which was a central ritual. Initiates progressed through these degrees, with each degree representing a symbolic death and rebirth, leading to spiritual enlightenment.
4. **Shamanic Initiations (Various Cultures)**: In many indigenous cultures, shamans undergo initiation rituals involving intense experiences such as fasting, isolation, and hallucinogenic journeys. These experiences are seen as symbolic deaths and rebirths, granting the shaman the ability to connect with the spirit world and heal the community.
5. **Ancient Mystery Schools (e.g., Pythagorean)**: The Pythagoreans, among others, operated mystery schools in ancient Greece. Initiates would go through a period of silence and philosophical contemplation, which was seen as a form of death to their previous way of thinking. Upon completion, they were “reborn” with new knowledge and insights.
6. **Native American Vision Quests**: Many Native American tribes have initiation rituals that involve vision quests. Initiates are sent into the wilderness to fast and seek a vision or encounter with a spirit guide. This experience is considered a symbolic death to one’s old self and a rebirth as a member of the tribe with a newfound purpose.
7. **Modern Initiatory Orders**: Some modern esoteric and fraternal organizations, such as the Freemasons and Rosicrucians, incorporate initiation rituals that involve symbolic deaths and rebirths. These rituals often emphasize moral and philosophical growth.
In all these cases, initiation rituals were intended to bring about profound personal transformation, often symbolized by death and rebirth. They were seen as a way for individuals to gain deeper insight, knowledge, and spiritual understanding, and to mark their transition to a higher level of consciousness or membership within a particular group or tradition.
The christians have a shortened version that involves dunking in water as symbolic of death
Indeed, the Christian practice you’re referring to is baptism, which involves the ritual of immersing a person in water or applying water to them as a symbol of purification, regeneration, and spiritual rebirth. Here’s a concise explanation of Christian baptism:
**Christian Baptism**:
– **Symbolism of Death and Resurrection**: Baptism in Christianity symbolizes a person’s identification with the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. The act of immersion in water is seen as a symbolic burial of the old, sinful self, and emerging from the water represents a new life in Christ, just as Jesus rose from the dead.
– **Sacramental Act**: Baptism is considered one of the sacraments in Christianity, a sacred act that conveys divine grace and initiates a person into the Christian faith. It is a rite of initiation and an important step in becoming a member of the Christian community.
– **Various Christian Traditions**: While the core symbolism of baptism is consistent across Christian denominations, there are variations in the age at which it is administered (infant baptism in some traditions, believer’s baptism in others) and the mode of administration (immersion, pouring, or sprinkling). These variations reflect differences in theological beliefs and practices among Christian groups.
– **Great Commission**: In the New Testament, Jesus instructed his disciples to baptize believers in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit (Matthew 28:19-20). This directive, known as the Great Commission, serves as the foundation for the Christian practice of baptism.
– **Baptismal Regeneration**: Some Christian traditions, such as Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, believe in the concept of baptismal regeneration, where baptism is considered necessary for the forgiveness of original sin and the reception of the Holy Spirit.
– **Profession of Faith**: In many Protestant denominations, believer’s baptism is practiced, which means individuals are baptized after making a personal confession of faith in Jesus Christ. This emphasizes a conscious decision to follow Christ.
– **Baptismal Symbolism**: The use of water in baptism symbolizes cleansing from sin and the beginning of a new life in Christ. It is a visible and public declaration of one’s faith and commitment to the Christian faith.
Christian baptism is a central and unifying ritual in Christianity, and its symbolism of death and rebirth is a powerful representation of the Christian belief in spiritual transformation through faith in Jesus Christ.
This is what I am coming to conclude from my more than 35 years of study in the subject of religion. That all religions I can name are based on a god of the heavens or from somewhere extra-terrestrial. There appears to be several groupings of genesis narratives with all of them including at least one catastrophic event, a flood. There is a smaller grouping that tells of a ‘saviour’ god who instructs the chosen recipients on surviving the coming event.
Your observations reflect some common themes and patterns that can be found in the study of various religious traditions and their creation narratives. While religious beliefs and mythologies vary greatly from culture to culture, there are indeed recurring themes, such as the concept of a divine or extraterrestrial origin, catastrophic events like floods, and the idea of a savior or prophetic figure. Here’s a concise overview:
1. **Divine or Extraterrestrial Origins**: Many religious traditions posit a divine or otherworldly origin for humanity and the world. Gods or higher beings are often believed to be responsible for creation, shaping the universe, and, in some cases, even engineering human existence. These gods are often associated with heavenly realms or extraterrestrial origins.
2. **Catastrophic Events**: Creation narratives across cultures frequently include accounts of cataclysmic events, such as floods or cosmic disasters. These events can symbolize purification, renewal, or a dramatic shift in the course of human history. The most famous flood story is found in the biblical account of Noah’s Ark, but similar stories appear in other cultures, such as the Sumerian flood myth.
3. **Savior or Prophetic Figures**: In some creation narratives, a savior or prophetic figure emerges to guide or save humanity from impending disaster. These figures are often chosen by the divine and impart knowledge or instructions on how to survive or navigate the challenges posed by the catastrophic event. In Christianity, Jesus is considered the savior figure who offers salvation to believers.
4. **Moral and Spiritual Lessons**: Creation myths and stories of catastrophe often carry moral and spiritual lessons. They may convey ideas about the consequences of human behavior, the importance of obedience to divine commands, or the need for spiritual transformation and redemption.
5. **Cultural and Regional Variations**: While there are common themes, it’s important to recognize that creation narratives and their associated themes vary significantly across different cultures and belief systems. These variations reflect the diversity of human thought and cultural expression.
6. **Interpretation and Symbolism**: The interpretation of these narratives can vary widely, even within a single religious tradition. Some adherents may view them as literal historical accounts, while others see them as symbolic or allegorical stories that convey deeper truths.
Your 35 years of study in religion have provided you with valuable insights into the shared and unique aspects of religious beliefs and narratives. The study of comparative religion can offer a deeper understanding of the human quest for meaning, the ways in which cultures express their spirituality, and the common threads that connect different belief systems.
What preflood narratives exist?
Pre-flood narratives, which describe events or stories that occur before a catastrophic flood, are found in several ancient cultures and mythologies around the world. These narratives often involve themes of divine warning, moral corruption, and the survival of a chosen few. Here are some notable pre-flood narratives from different cultures:
1. **The Epic of Gilgamesh (Mesopotamia)**: The Epic of Gilgamesh, one of the earliest known works of literature, includes a flood narrative that predates the biblical account of Noah’s Ark. In this narrative, the gods decide to flood the earth due to human corruption. The hero, Utnapishtim, is warned by the god Ea and builds a boat to save himself, his family, and various animals.
2. **The Atrahasis Epic (Mesopotamia)**: The Atrahasis Epic is another Mesopotamian text that contains a flood story. It tells of the gods creating humans and later deciding to send a flood to wipe out humanity due to overpopulation and noise. Atrahasis, a sage, is instructed to build an ark to survive the flood.
3. **The Matsya Purana (Hinduism)**: In Hinduism, the Matsya Purana tells the story of Lord Vishnu taking the form of a fish (Matsya) to save the sage Manu and a select group of plants and animals from a great deluge. This narrative is seen as a precursor to the concept of avatars in Hinduism.
4. **The Popol Vuh (Maya Civilization)**: The Popol Vuh is a creation myth from the Maya civilization, which includes a flood narrative. In this story, the gods create humanity but become dissatisfied and send a flood to destroy humans. The hero twins, Hunahpu and Xbalanque, ultimately survive and go on to become celestial bodies.
5. **The Nuwa and Fuxi Legend (Chinese Mythology)**: Chinese mythology features the story of Nuwa and Fuxi, legendary deities who are credited with creating humanity. In some versions of the myth, they are said to have survived a great flood by using the legs of a giant tortoise to prop themselves above the waters.
6. **The Maori Myth of Tawhaki and Hina (Maori Mythology)**: Maori mythology includes a flood narrative involving the hero Tawhaki and his grandmother Hina. Tawhaki rescues his grandmother from the rising waters by climbing the heavens.
7. **The Flood of Deucalion (Greek Mythology)**: Greek mythology has its own version of a great flood, associated with the story of Deucalion and Pyrrha. Zeus sends a flood to punish humanity, but Deucalion and Pyrrha survive by following the advice of the Titan Prometheus.
These pre-flood narratives often share common themes, such as divine displeasure with human behavior, the survival of a chosen few through divine intervention, and the subsequent repopulation of the earth after the floodwaters recede. These stories reflect the universal human fascination with floods as dramatic and transformative events and serve as cautionary tales about the consequences of human actions.
list those that are most similar
The most similar pre-flood narratives are those from the Mesopotamian cultures, including the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Atrahasis Epic, as they share striking similarities with the biblical account of Noah’s Ark. Here’s a brief comparison of these narratives:
1. **Epic of Gilgamesh (Mesopotamia)**:
– In the Epic of Gilgamesh, the gods decide to flood the earth due to human corruption and noise.
– The hero, Utnapishtim, is warned by the god Ea about the impending flood.
– Utnapishtim builds a boat, loads it with his family, artisans, and various animals.
– The flood lasts for six days and nights.
– After the floodwaters recede, Utnapishtim sends out birds (a dove, a swallow, and a raven) to check for dry land.
– Utnapishtim offers sacrifices, and the gods, smelling the sweet aroma, gather “like flies” around him.
2. **Atrahasis Epic (Mesopotamia)**:
– In the Atrahasis Epic, the gods decide to send a flood to wipe out humanity due to overpopulation and noise.
– Atrahasis, a sage, is warned by the god Enki (Ea) about the impending flood.
– Atrahasis is instructed to build an ark and take animals on board.
– The flood lasts for seven days and seven nights.
– After the flood, Atrahasis offers sacrifices to the gods.
These Mesopotamian flood narratives share many common elements with the biblical account of Noah’s Ark found in the Book of Genesis. The themes of divine displeasure with humanity’s behavior, the construction of an ark to save a select few, the duration of the flood, and the offering of sacrifices after the flood are all present in these narratives. This has led scholars to study and compare these stories, exploring potential cultural exchanges or influences over time.
COmpare and contrast the story of The Matsya Purana (Hinduism) with creation story of the Sumerian
The story of the Matsya Purana in Hinduism and the Sumerian creation myth, specifically the Enuma Elish, are both ancient narratives that describe aspects of creation and divine intervention. While they come from different cultural and religious backgrounds, there are some points of comparison and contrast between these two creation stories:
**Similarities:**
1. **Divine Beings and Creation**: Both stories feature divine beings as central figures in the creation of the world. In the Matsya Purana, it is Lord Vishnu who takes the form of a fish (Matsya) to save humanity and the world. In the Enuma Elish, the god Marduk plays a significant role in the creation of the world from the defeated goddess Tiamat.
2. **Conflict and Chaos**: Both narratives involve a conflict or chaotic situation at the outset. In the Matsya Purana, the world is threatened by a catastrophic flood, while in the Enuma Elish, there is a primordial conflict between the gods and the chaotic forces of Tiamat.
3. **Role of Water**: Water plays a pivotal role in both stories. In the Matsya Purana, the floodwaters are central to the narrative, and in the Enuma Elish, the story begins with the waters of chaos.
**Contrasts:**
1. **Religious Context**: The Matsya Purana is a sacred text in Hinduism, and its narrative is integrated into the broader religious and philosophical framework of Hindu belief. In contrast, the Enuma Elish is part of Mesopotamian mythology and not a religious scripture in the same sense. It reflects the cosmogony of ancient Mesopotamia.
2. **Gods and Pantheon**: Hinduism is a polytheistic religion with a vast pantheon of gods and goddesses. The Matsya Purana involves Lord Vishnu, one of the principal deities in Hinduism. In contrast, Sumerian religion had its own pantheon of gods, and the Enuma Elish highlights the role of Marduk and Tiamat.
3. **Themes and Symbolism**: The Matsya Purana emphasizes themes of preservation and regeneration, with Lord Vishnu’s role as a savior figure. In the Enuma Elish, the story revolves around themes of cosmic order, creation through conflict, and the rise of Marduk as the chief god.
4. **Cosmological Details**: The two stories offer distinct cosmological details. The Matsya Purana focuses on the rescue of humans, animals, and plants from the flood through Lord Vishnu’s intervention. The Enuma Elish describes the formation of the world from the body of the slain goddess Tiamat.
5. **Cultural and Geographic Context**: The Matsya Purana originates from the Indian subcontinent, while the Enuma Elish comes from ancient Mesopotamia (modern-day Iraq). These distinct cultural and geographical contexts influence the symbolism, terminology, and cosmogonic elements in each narrative.
In summary, while both the Matsya Purana and the Enuma Elish involve divine beings, creation, and conflicts, they are fundamentally different in terms of their religious and cultural contexts, theological implications, and specific narrative details. These stories provide insights into the diverse ways in which ancient cultures conceptualized the origins of the world and the role of divine forces in shaping it.
could it be excused to think of the Enuma Elish and the Epic of gilgamesh and perhaps atrahasis as all chapters from one book?
It’s not accurate to consider the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis as chapters from one book in the conventional sense, as they were written in different times and by different authors in ancient Mesopotamia. However, it is appropriate to view them as related literary and mythological texts that are part of the rich cultural and literary heritage of Mesopotamia. Here’s a breakdown of their relationships:
1. **Shared Cultural Context**: The Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis all originate from ancient Mesopotamia, specifically from Sumerian and Akkadian cultures. They share common cultural elements, symbols, and motifs that were prevalent in the region.
2. **Similar Themes**: These texts explore themes that were of significance in Mesopotamian thought, including creation, the relationship between gods and humans, the struggle for power, and the consequences of divine actions. The Enuma Elish deals with the creation of the world, the Epic of Gilgamesh is an epic of heroic and moral themes, and the Atrahasis addresses the flood narrative.
3. **Cultural Influences**: It is likely that these texts influenced one another to some extent. For example, the Enuma Elish, which is a creation myth, may have influenced the cosmological elements found in the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Atrahasis.
4. **Different Literary Forms**: While they share common cultural themes, each text has its own distinct literary form and purpose. The Enuma Elish is a creation myth, the Epic of Gilgamesh is an epic poem, and the Atrahasis is closer to a mythological narrative or legend. They serve different literary and cultural functions.
5. **Different Authors and Time Periods**: These texts were composed at different times by different authors. The Enuma Elish is believed to have originated in the Old Babylonian period, while the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Atrahasis come from different periods in Mesopotamian history. The Epic of Gilgamesh, for example, is attributed to the poet Sin-leqi-unninni.
In summary, while these texts are not chapters from a single book, they are closely related in terms of their cultural context, themes, and influence on Mesopotamian literature and thought. They collectively contribute to our understanding of the rich mythological and literary tradition of ancient Mesopotamia.
Much like the books of the JC bible were written in different times as well, does that make them discordant to the theme?
The fact that different books of the Bible were written in different times and by various authors does not necessarily make them discordant to the overarching themes of the Bible. In fact, this diversity of authorship and historical context is a characteristic of the Bible and contributes to its richness and complexity. Here’s a concise overview of how the diverse books of the Bible can be viewed in relation to its themes:
1. **Unity in Diversity**: While the Bible is composed of many different books, it is considered a unified sacred text by believers because it centers around common theological themes and narratives. These themes include monotheism, the covenant between God and humanity, the concept of salvation, moral and ethical guidance, and the role of prophetic figures and saviors.
2. **Progressive Revelation**: Many religious scholars and theologians view the Bible as a record of God’s progressive revelation to humanity. The books of the Bible were written in various historical and cultural contexts, reflecting the evolving understanding of God’s will and the relationship between God and humanity.
3. **Interconnected Themes**: Despite the diversity of the books, there are interconnected themes that run throughout the Bible. For example, the Old Testament lays the theological groundwork for the New Testament, with themes of promise and fulfillment, the anticipation of a Messiah, and the idea of salvation through faith.
4. **Different Literary Forms**: The Bible contains a wide range of literary forms, including historical narratives, poetry, prophecy, letters, and apocalyptic literature. Each of these forms serves a distinct purpose within the broader narrative of the Bible, but they collectively contribute to the expression of key theological concepts.
5. **Theological Harmony**: Many believers see a theological harmony in the Bible, even though individual books may have unique emphases or perspectives. They view the diverse books as part of a larger theological tapestry that unfolds over time.
6. **Exegesis and Hermeneutics**: The interpretation of the Bible often involves exegesis (the critical analysis of the text) and hermeneutics (the study of interpretation). Scholars and theologians consider the historical, cultural, and literary context of each book when interpreting its meaning and relevance within the broader biblical narrative.
In summary, while the Bible comprises diverse books written at different times and by various authors, it is seen as a cohesive and meaningful whole by believers. The diverse nature of the Bible’s composition adds depth and nuance to its exploration of theological and moral themes, and its unity is often found in the shared understanding of God’s relationship with humanity and the unfolding plan of salvation.
As I said, the 3 books mentioned earier all share some similar theme, right?
Yes, you are correct. The three texts you mentioned earlier— the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis—all share some similar themes, especially in the context of their Mesopotamian origins. These common themes include:
1. **Divine Beings and Creation**: All three texts involve divine beings as central figures in the creation of the world or in significant events. For example, in the Enuma Elish, the god Marduk plays a role in the creation of the world, in the Epic of Gilgamesh, gods and goddesses are integral to the narrative, and in the Atrahasis, divine beings are involved in the decision to send a flood.
2. **Conflict and Chaos**: Each of these narratives begins with a state of conflict or chaos. In the Enuma Elish, there is a primordial struggle between the gods and Tiamat, the goddess of chaos. In the Epic of Gilgamesh, the hero faces inner and outer conflicts, and in the Atrahasis, there is turmoil among the gods over humanity’s noise.
3. **Divine Intervention**: Divine beings in these stories often intervene in human affairs. For instance, in the Epic of Gilgamesh, the gods decide to send the Great Flood as a form of divine intervention. In the Atrahasis, Enki (Ea) intervenes by instructing Atrahasis to build an ark.
4. **Cosmic or Natural Catastrophe**: Catastrophic events, such as the creation of the world or a flood, play significant roles in these narratives. In the Enuma Elish, the world is formed from the body of the defeated Tiamat. In the Epic of Gilgamesh, the Great Flood is a central event. In the Atrahasis, the gods send a flood to address the problem of human overpopulation.
5. **Survival and Renewal**: In each narrative, there is an element of survival and renewal. Characters or entities survive the cataclysmic events, leading to the renewal or continuation of life and civilization.
6. **Moral and Ethical Implications**: These stories often contain moral and ethical elements, reflecting the values and beliefs of the cultures that produced them. They explore concepts such as the consequences of human actions, the role of humans in the divine plan, and the relationship between gods and mortals.
While these themes are common among these three texts, each text has its own unique narrative, characters, and cultural context. As a result, while they share similarities, they are also distinct in their details and convey unique cultural perspectives on these common themes.
These books all come from teh same culture over time, right?
Yes, the three texts you mentioned—the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis—all come from the same general cultural region and time period. They are part of the literary and mythological heritage of ancient Mesopotamia, which is often considered one of the earliest and most influential civilizations in human history. Here are some key points about their shared cultural context:
1. **Geographic Region**: Mesopotamia was located in the area that corresponds to modern-day Iraq, parts of Iran, Syria, and Turkey. It was situated between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, making it one of the world’s earliest cradles of civilization.
2. **Historical Period**: These texts originated in Mesopotamia during various historical periods, primarily in the third and second millennia BCE. The Enuma Elish, for instance, dates back to the Old Babylonian period (around the 18th century BCE), while the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Atrahasis are from different periods within Mesopotamian history.
3. **Cuneiform Script**: These texts were written in cuneiform script, one of the earliest systems of writing. Cuneiform was used in various Mesopotamian cultures, including the Sumerians, Akkadians, and Babylonians.
4. **Shared Mythological Elements**: These texts share common mythological elements, deities, and themes that were prominent in the religious and cultural milieu of ancient Mesopotamia. For example, the god Marduk, who features in the Enuma Elish, was a significant figure in Babylonian mythology.
5. **Cultural Exchange**: Mesopotamia was a region of cultural exchange and interaction among various city-states and cultures. This exchange contributed to the dissemination of myths and stories across the region.
6. **Cultural and Religious Significance**: These texts had cultural and religious significance within Mesopotamian societies. They played roles in the expression of cultural identity, religious beliefs, and moral values.
While these texts share a common cultural and historical context, it’s important to note that they may have been composed by different authors or communities within Mesopotamia and at different points in its history. As a result, while they share certain themes and mythological elements, they also have unique characteristics and narratives that reflect the specific cultural and historical circumstances of their respective periods.
I would argune that the book of genesis is significantly different than the book of psalms as well. Your closing remarks seem ti indicate that there is no value in trying to include all three books as a more complete picture of the dynamics of the religion of ancient mesopotamia. I think there is.
I appreciate your perspective, and I want to clarify that the comparison between the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis, as well as their relationship to the culture of ancient Mesopotamia, was not intended to diminish their value or significance. Each of these texts, including the Book of Genesis and the Book of Psalms in the Bible, holds its own unique importance and provides valuable insights into the beliefs, values, and cultural dynamics of their respective societies.
Here are a few key points to consider:
1. **Diverse Literary Forms**: The texts you’ve mentioned come from diverse literary forms and genres. The Enuma Elish is a creation myth, the Epic of Gilgamesh is an epic poem, the Atrahasis is closer to a mythological narrative, the Book of Genesis contains both historical narratives and genealogies, and the Book of Psalms is a collection of songs and poetry. Each form serves a specific purpose within its cultural and religious context.
2. **Different Cultural and Religious Contexts**: While the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis are related to Mesopotamian culture, the Book of Genesis and the Book of Psalms are part of the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) and have their own distinct cultural and religious contexts. They reflect the beliefs and traditions of the Israelites.
3. **Comparative Study**: Comparative study of these texts is indeed valuable for understanding the broader cultural and religious milieu of the ancient Near East, as it allows scholars and readers to identify common themes, motifs, and influences. This can enhance our appreciation of the interconnectedness of ancient civilizations and their literary and religious traditions.
4. **Theological and Cultural Diversity**: It’s important to recognize that each text represents a particular theological and cultural perspective. The diversity of texts within and across cultures provides a more comprehensive view of the complex tapestry of human spirituality and thought.
In summary, while these texts may originate from different cultures and literary traditions, they all contribute to our understanding of ancient religious and cultural dynamics. Exploring these texts collectively and individually enriches our knowledge of the beliefs, values, and narratives that shaped the ancient world. Each text has its own significance and value in the study of history, religion, and literature.
So lets’ explore the themes of the 3 books from sumer. list them chonologically
Certainly, let’s explore the key themes of the three major Mesopotamian texts you mentioned— the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis—in chronological order of their historical periods:
1. **Enuma Elish (c. 18th century BCE)**:
– **Creation and Cosmogony**: The Enuma Elish is primarily a creation myth that describes the formation of the world and the cosmos. It explains how the gods came into being and how the universe was organized.
– **Divine Conflict and Power Dynamics**: The narrative revolves around the struggle for power among the gods. The god Marduk’s rise to supreme authority after defeating Tiamat, the goddess of chaos, reflects themes of divine conflict and the establishment of order.
– **Cosmic Order**: The Enuma Elish emphasizes the concept of cosmic order (cosmos) emerging from primordial chaos (chaosmos) through divine intervention. The creation of the world is seen as the result of divine planning and design.
– **The Role of Divine Speech**: The text highlights the power of divine speech and the act of speaking as a creative force. Marduk’s use of language and incantations to control and shape the universe is a prominent theme.
2. **Epic of Gilgamesh (c. 18th-17th centuries BCE)**:
– **Heroic Journey and Quest**: The Epic of Gilgamesh centers on the journey of the hero Gilgamesh, who embarks on a quest for immortality. The hero’s journey and his pursuit of wisdom and meaning are central themes.
– **Friendship and Companionship**: The epic explores the theme of friendship through the relationship between Gilgamesh and Enkidu. Their bond highlights the importance of human connection and companionship.
– **Mortality and Death**: A recurring theme in the epic is the inevitability of human mortality. Gilgamesh’s quest for immortality reflects humanity’s search for ways to overcome the limits of life and confront the reality of death.
– **Nature and the Natural World**: The story incorporates themes related to nature and the natural world, including the Cedar Forest and the gods associated with natural elements.
3. **Atrahasis (c. 17th century BCE)**:
– **Divine Decision to Send a Flood**: The Atrahasis narrative focuses on the gods’ decision to send a great flood to address the problem of human overpopulation and noise. This event marks a significant theme in the text.
– **Survival and Divine Intervention**: Atrahasis, the protagonist, receives divine instructions on how to build an ark to survive the impending flood. The theme of survival through divine intervention is central.
– **Creation of Humans**: The text also provides an account of the creation of humans by the gods and their role as servants of the divine.
– **Moral Themes**: The story touches on themes of morality, divine justice, and the consequences of human actions, particularly in relation to overpopulation and environmental degradation.
These three texts from ancient Mesopotamia reflect a rich tapestry of themes, including creation, conflict, order, heroism, friendship, mortality, divine intervention, and moral considerations. They offer valuable insights into the beliefs, values, and cultural context of their time.
Now the time spans of each
Certainly, here are the approximate time spans for each of the three major Mesopotamian texts— the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis:
1. **Enuma Elish (c. 18th century BCE)**:
– The Enuma Elish is estimated to have been composed during the 18th century BCE. It originated in ancient Mesopotamia and is one of the earliest known creation myths.
2. **Epic of Gilgamesh (c. 18th-17th centuries BCE)**:
– The Epic of Gilgamesh is believed to have been composed during the 18th to 17th centuries BCE. It is one of the earliest known epic poems and literary works in human history.
3. **Atrahasis (c. 17th century BCE)**:
– The Atrahasis narrative is dated to the 17th century BCE. It also belongs to the literary and mythological tradition of ancient Mesopotamia.
These texts emerged during the same general historical period in ancient Mesopotamia and are significant not only for their literary and mythological contributions but also for the insights they provide into the beliefs, values, and culture of their time.
No, in the stories they tell, such as the cosmogeny of the heavens, what are the timeframes discussed in each ?
I apologize for the misunderstanding. The three Mesopotamian texts you mentioned— the Enuma Elish, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Atrahasis—do not explicitly provide detailed timeframes for the cosmogony of the heavens in the same way that some other creation myths do. These texts primarily focus on the themes of creation, divine conflict, and the origins of the world and humanity, but they do not provide specific chronological timelines for the creation of the heavens and the cosmos.
The Enuma Elish primarily describes the creation of the world and the establishment of cosmic order through the victory of Marduk over Tiamat. It emphasizes the organization of the cosmos but does not provide a specific timeframe for this process.
The Epic of Gilgamesh, while containing elements of cosmogony and descriptions of the gods, is primarily centered on the hero Gilgamesh’s journey, quests, and relationships. It does not delve into detailed cosmogonical timelines.
The Atrahasis focuses on the gods’ decision to send a flood as a response to human overpopulation and noise. While it discusses the creation of humans by the gods, it does not provide a specific chronological account of the creation of the heavens or the cosmos.
These texts are more concerned with the themes of creation, order, conflict, and human experiences rather than providing scientific or chronological details about the origins of the universe or the heavens.
So the age of gilgamesh is not mentioned when he died?
The age at which Gilgamesh died is not explicitly mentioned in the standard version of the Epic of Gilgamesh. The epic provides an account of Gilgamesh’s heroic exploits, his journey to seek immortality, and his eventual realization of the limits of human mortality. However, it does not specify the exact age at which he died.
The epic does indicate that Gilgamesh was a historical figure and that he was a king of Uruk, a city-state in ancient Mesopotamia. Some versions of the Gilgamesh legend and related texts from Mesopotamia provide details about his reign and accomplishments, but the age at which he passed away is not a central focus of the epic itself.
The primary themes of the Epic of Gilgamesh revolve around the nature of heroism, friendship, the quest for wisdom, and the acceptance of mortality. The epic is more concerned with the hero’s journey and his quest for meaning and understanding in the face of mortality rather than providing specific biographical details about his life and death.
What, if any, ancient accounts tell of a time before this one, like Atlantis or even before?
The idea of a lost or advanced civilization that predates our own has been a recurring theme in various ancient accounts and myths. Atlantis is perhaps the most famous example of such a concept, but there are other accounts and legends that suggest the existence of earlier civilizations or periods of advanced knowledge. Here are a few examples:
1. **Atlantis**: Atlantis is a legendary island first described by the ancient Greek philosopher Plato in his dialogues “Timaeus” and “Critias.” According to Plato, Atlantis was a powerful and advanced civilization that existed around 9,000 years before his time (approximately 11,000 years ago). Atlantis ultimately fell out of favor with the gods and was submerged into the sea. While Atlantis is a well-known legend, there is no archaeological evidence to support its existence as described by Plato.
2. **Lemuria and Mu**: These are two hypothetical lost continents or civilizations that have been proposed in various speculative theories. Lemuria was initially proposed in the 19th century as a land bridge that might have connected Madagascar to India. Mu, sometimes called “Pacifica,” is another lost continent that has been proposed as a precursor to known civilizations. Both ideas lack scientific evidence and are considered pseudoscientific or speculative.
3. **Mythical Golden and Silver Ages**: Many ancient cultures, including Greek, Hindu, and Norse, have myths and legends that describe earlier ages of humanity marked by prosperity, peace, and advanced knowledge. These ages are often referred to as “Golden Ages” or “Silver Ages” and are seen as times when humans lived in harmony with the gods or experienced a higher level of enlightenment. These myths suggest the cyclical nature of history, with periods of decline and renewal.
4. **Yugas in Hinduism**: Hindu cosmology includes the concept of Yugas, which are cycles of time. The Yugas are said to gradually decline in virtue and knowledge, with the Satya Yuga being the most virtuous and enlightened age and the Kali Yuga representing the lowest point in human history. The cycle then repeats.
5. **Native American Creation Myths**: Some Native American tribes have creation myths that describe previous worlds or civilizations that were destroyed or submerged in water. These myths often emphasize themes of rebirth and renewal.
It’s important to note that these accounts and legends are typically considered myths, legends, or speculative ideas rather than historical or scientific facts. While they reflect human fascination with the idea of lost civilizations or earlier advanced cultures, there is no empirical evidence to support their existence. Archaeology and historical research focus on tangible evidence and documented history, which has limitations in exploring events or civilizations that might have existed in prehistory.
Of the ancient texts, which are the most comprehenisive and accurate in astronomy/astrometrics.
Several ancient texts from different cultures provide valuable insights into astronomy and astrometry. These texts vary in their comprehensiveness and accuracy, with some being more detailed and reliable than others. Here are a few ancient texts known for their contributions to early astronomy and astrometry:
1. **Almagest (Ptolemy, c. 2nd century CE)**:
– The “Almagest” by Claudius Ptolemy is one of the most influential works in the history of astronomy. It presents a comprehensive geocentric model of the universe and includes detailed descriptions of the motions of celestial bodies, star catalogues, and mathematical techniques for predicting planetary positions. While the geocentric model is now outdated, the “Almagest” played a crucial role in shaping medieval and Renaissance astronomy.
2. **Zij al-Sindhind (Indian Astronomers, various authors, 8th-10th centuries CE)**:
– The “Zij al-Sindhind” is a collection of Islamic astronomical texts that drew heavily from Indian and Greek sources. These texts introduced new astronomical instruments and mathematical techniques to Islamic and medieval European astronomy. They include observations of the positions of stars and planets.
3. **Astronomical Diaries (Babylonian Astronomers, various dates)**:
– The Babylonian Astronomical Diaries are a series of cuneiform tablets that contain daily records of astronomical observations made by ancient Babylonian astronomers. They provide valuable information on celestial events such as lunar eclipses, planetary positions, and the movements of comets.
4. **Han Shu (Book of Han, 2nd century CE)**:
– The “Han Shu” is a Chinese historical text that includes information on astronomy during the Han Dynasty. It contains records of solar and lunar eclipses, planetary positions, and the movements of celestial bodies. Chinese astronomers were known for their accurate observations.
5. **Surya Siddhanta (Various Indian Authors, dates vary)**:
– The “Surya Siddhanta” is an ancient Indian astronomical text that provides detailed information about the solar system, including planetary positions and calculations for eclipses. While some of its astronomical constants are outdated, it reflects the advanced state of Indian astronomy at the time.
6. **Maya Codices (Maya Civilization, various dates)**:
– The Maya Codices are a collection of surviving pre-Columbian books from the Maya civilization. They contain detailed astronomical and calendrical information, including the Maya calendar systems and astronomical events.
It’s important to note that while these texts represent significant achievements in their respective cultures and time periods, they also had limitations and inaccuracies by modern astronomical standards. Ancient astronomy often relied on different cosmological models and lacked the precision of modern astronomical techniques. Nonetheless, these texts provide valuable historical and cultural insights into early human attempts to understand and document the movements of celestial bodies.
How have we dated Adams calendar?
“Adam’s Calendar” is the name given to a collection of stone monoliths and rock formations in South Africa, which some proponents claim to be a prehistoric calendar. However, it’s important to note that the claims about the age and function of Adam’s Calendar are not widely accepted by the scientific community, and its dating remains a topic of controversy.
The proponents of Adam’s Calendar suggest that it is a site dating back tens of thousands of years and that it aligns with various astronomical events, such as solstices and equinoxes. They base these claims on the positioning of the stones and the idea that the site served as an ancient calendar or observatory.
However, there are several challenges and controversies surrounding the dating and interpretation of Adam’s Calendar:
1. **Lack of Archaeological Consensus**: The claims made about Adam’s Calendar have not been widely accepted or verified by mainstream archaeologists and scientists. The site’s age and purpose are subject to ongoing debate.
2. **Radiometric Dating**: Radiometric dating methods, such as carbon dating, are typically used to determine the age of archaeological sites and artifacts. Without credible radiometric dating results, it is difficult to establish the site’s precise age.
3. **Geological Formation**: Some geologists have suggested that the features of Adam’s Calendar may be a natural geological formation rather than a human-made structure.
4. **Astronomical Alignments**: While there are claims about astronomical alignments at the site, these alignments are also disputed, and they may not necessarily indicate intentional human construction for astronomical purposes.
In summary, the dating of Adam’s Calendar remains controversial and lacks the consensus and scientific validation typically required for archaeological sites. Further research and investigation are needed to establish its age, purpose, and significance. Until then, it remains a topic of interest and debate among certain groups but is not widely recognized as an ancient calendar by the broader scientific community.
Is there an ‘eastern pointer’ for adams calendar?
The term “eastern pointer” is not a recognized or widely accepted concept in mainstream archaeology or astronomy. The claims and terminology associated with “Adam’s Calendar” are often associated with alternative theories and interpretations, and they are not part of the established scientific understanding of ancient sites or astronomical alignments.
In the case of “Adam’s Calendar,” proponents suggest that certain stone monoliths or features at the site may align with astronomical phenomena or point in specific directions, but these claims have not been widely verified or accepted by the scientific community. The site’s dating, purpose, and astronomical significance are subjects of controversy and debate.
It’s important to approach such claims with critical scrutiny and to rely on established archaeological and astronomical methods for the study and interpretation of ancient sites and their potential alignments with celestial events. Without rigorous scientific evidence and consensus, claims about “eastern pointers” or other astronomical features at Adam’s Calendar should be viewed with caution.
I have seen this site and ineed one could say that there appears to be some organization to it, but I also see the potential hazards in pardoilia
Your observations about the site known as “Adam’s Calendar” and your recognition of potential pareidolia are valid and important considerations. Pareidolia is a psychological phenomenon in which humans perceive familiar patterns or shapes, often faces or recognizable objects, in random or ambiguous stimuli. This tendency can lead people to see patterns and structures that may not necessarily have been intentionally created.
When evaluating sites like “Adam’s Calendar” or any other ancient or natural formations, it’s essential to approach them with a critical and objective mindset. Here are some key points to keep in mind:
1. **Scientific Investigation**: The study of archaeological sites and their alignments with astronomical phenomena typically involves rigorous scientific methods, including radiometric dating, astronomical calculations, and careful documentation.
2. **Context Matters**: Understanding the cultural and historical context of a site is crucial for interpreting its significance. Archaeological evidence, artifacts, and historical records can provide valuable context.
3. **Skepticism and Peer Review**: Claims about the age, purpose, or astronomical significance of a site should undergo peer review within the scientific community. Skepticism is a fundamental part of the scientific process.
4. **Natural vs. Human-Made**: Some features that appear organized or structured may be natural formations. Distinguishing between natural and human-made features is an essential aspect of archaeological research.
5. **Cultural Beliefs**: It’s common for sites like “Adam’s Calendar” to be associated with cultural beliefs and narratives. These beliefs may not always align with scientific interpretations.
In the case of “Adam’s Calendar” and similar sites, it’s valuable to approach them with curiosity but also with a critical mindset. Scientific investigation and peer-reviewed research are essential for determining the true nature, age, and purpose of such sites. While they may hold cultural or historical significance, claims about astronomical alignments or ancient calendars should be supported by robust evidence and subjected to scrutiny by experts in relevant fields.
Aren’t ancient gold mine shafts found in the area?
Yes, there are ancient gold mine shafts and mining activity found in the region surrounding “Adam’s Calendar” in Mpumalanga, South Africa. These gold mines are part of a broader complex of ancient mining sites in the area that date back thousands of years. The most famous of these ancient mines is the “Lydenburg Heads” gold mine, located not far from “Adam’s Calendar.”
These ancient gold mines are associated with the ancestors of the indigenous peoples of southern Africa, including the Bantu-speaking peoples. Gold was a valuable resource in the region, and mining activities were conducted to extract the precious metal.
The presence of these ancient gold mines and associated archaeological artifacts demonstrates the advanced metallurgical and mining skills of the ancient inhabitants of the area. These mining activities are significant historical and cultural aspects of the region’s heritage.
It’s important to distinguish between the archaeological evidence related to gold mining and the claims associated with “Adam’s Calendar.” While there is tangible evidence of ancient mining activities in the region, the claims about “Adam’s Calendar” being an ancient calendar or observatory are more speculative and remain a subject of debate within archaeological and scientific communities.
What is the estimated ages of the mines?
The ancient gold mines in the region surrounding “Adam’s Calendar” in Mpumalanga, South Africa, are estimated to date back to various periods in antiquity. These mines were active over an extended period, and their age can vary depending on the specific site and archaeological evidence. Here are some general estimates for the ages of these ancient gold mines:
1. **Early Mining Activity (approx. 1,500-2,000 years ago)**: Some of the oldest gold mining activity in the region is believed to have taken place around 1,500 to 2,000 years ago. During this period, indigenous peoples in the region, including the ancestors of the Bantu-speaking groups, engaged in small-scale mining and metallurgical activities.
2. **Medieval Period (approx. 800-1,000 years ago)**: Gold mining in the region continued and expanded during the medieval period. The archaeological evidence suggests that mining operations became more organized and extensive during this time.
3. **Later Historical Periods**: Gold mining activities in the region continued into more recent historical periods, with various societies and communities engaging in mining activities. These activities were often linked to trade networks and the exchange of valuable commodities.
4. **Modern Era**: In more recent times, gold mining in the area has transitioned to modern mining methods and operations. These contemporary mining activities are separate from the ancient mining sites and are conducted for commercial purposes.
It’s important to note that these estimates are general approximations based on archaeological evidence and historical records. The dating of ancient mining sites can vary, and further archaeological research and dating techniques are often employed to refine the chronological understanding of these sites.
The presence of ancient gold mines in the region is a testament to the long history of mining and metallurgy in southern Africa and the skill and knowledge of the indigenous peoples who engaged in these activities over the centuries.
Do we know aht was being done with the gold?
The use of gold obtained from ancient mines in southern Africa varied depending on the time period and the specific culture or society involved. Gold had significant cultural, economic, and symbolic value, and its utilization evolved over time. Here are some of the primary purposes for which ancient peoples in the region used gold:
1. **Ornaments and Jewelry**: One of the earliest and most common uses of gold was for creating ornaments and jewelry. Gold objects, such as necklaces, bracelets, rings, earrings, and headdresses, were crafted for personal adornment. These items often had intricate designs and served both aesthetic and status-related purposes.
2. **Currency and Trade**: Gold also served as a form of currency and a medium of exchange in trade networks. It was highly valued for its portability, durability, and universal acceptance. Gold objects, including gold dust and gold beads, were used in trade transactions with neighboring regions.
3. **Ritual and Religious Objects**: Gold had spiritual and religious significance in many ancient African societies. It was used to create sacred objects, idols, and ceremonial items used in religious rituals and ceremonies.
4. **Ceremonial and Royal Regalia**: Gold was associated with rulership and authority. Kings, chiefs, and other elite individuals often wore gold jewelry and regalia as symbols of their power and prestige. Gold was used in the creation of crowns, staffs, and other royal accouterments.
5. **Burial and Funerary Practices**: Gold objects were sometimes buried with the deceased as part of funerary practices. These items were considered valuable offerings to accompany the deceased into the afterlife.
6. **Artistic and Decorative Objects**: Gold was used to create intricate artistic and decorative objects, including figurines, masks, and sculptures. These objects showcased the craftsmanship and artistic skills of ancient societies.
7. **Trade and Diplomacy**: Gold was also used in diplomatic exchanges and as gifts to forge alliances or maintain peaceful relations with neighboring groups.
The specific uses of gold could vary widely from one society to another and over different historical periods. The importance and symbolism of gold in these ancient cultures contributed to its multifaceted use in various aspects of life, from personal adornment to economic transactions and religious rituals.
No, I mean specifically for what reason was gfold mining performed there. Like for a king or some ruler?
The ancient gold mining in the region surrounding “Adam’s Calendar” and other areas in southern Africa served various purposes, including providing gold for the use of rulers, elites, and the broader society. While the specific motivations and beneficiaries of gold mining activities can vary across different time periods and cultures, here are some key reasons why gold mining was conducted:
1. **Rulers and Elites**: Gold mining often supplied gold for rulers, kings, chiefs, and elites. Gold was a symbol of power, wealth, and prestige. Rulers would wear gold jewelry and regalia as a demonstration of their authority and status.
2. **Trade and Commerce**: Gold served as a valuable commodity for trade and commerce. It was used in interregional and long-distance trade networks, and gold objects were exchanged for other goods, including luxury items, exotic materials, and resources.
3. **Rituals and Ceremonies**: Gold was used in religious rituals and ceremonies. It had sacred and spiritual significance in many African societies. Gold objects, such as masks, idols, and ceremonial items, played roles in religious practices and rituals.
4. **Funerary Practices**: Gold objects were sometimes buried with individuals as part of funerary practices. These items were considered valuable offerings to accompany the deceased into the afterlife. Some cultures believed that gold had protective or guiding properties for the deceased.
5. **Artistic Expression**: Gold was used for artistic and decorative purposes. Skilled artisans crafted intricate gold objects and figurines that showcased the creativity and artistry of the society. These objects could be used for display or ceremonial purposes.
6. **Status and Social Hierarchy**: Gold was a marker of social status and hierarchy. Access to gold and gold objects could indicate one’s position in society. It was also used as a form of currency for transactions and exchanges within the society.
7. **Diplomacy and Alliances**: Gold could be used as diplomatic gifts to establish and maintain alliances with neighboring groups or societies. It played a role in diplomacy and relations with neighboring regions.
The specific reasons for gold mining could vary from one society to another and might encompass a combination of these purposes. In many cases, gold mining was multifaceted and served the needs of rulers, elites, religious institutions, and the broader community. The presence of ancient gold mines in the region underscores the cultural, economic, and symbolic significance of gold in these societies.
For what reason was gold imporrtant to ancients peoples since it bears no intrinsic value, just another rock
Gold’s value to ancient peoples and civilizations, despite lacking intrinsic practical utility like food or shelter, can be attributed to several key factors:
1. **Symbolic and Cultural Significance**: Gold has been prized for its beauty, rarity, and malleability. Its brilliant color and resistance to corrosion made it stand out among other metals. Its rarity contributed to its perception as a precious and valuable substance. These aesthetic qualities gave gold a unique and enduring appeal, making it a symbol of beauty and luxury.
2. **Status and Prestige**: Gold’s scarcity made it a status symbol. Owning and displaying gold objects, such as jewelry, regalia, and ornaments, signified wealth, power, and social standing. Rulers, elites, and high-ranking individuals used gold to showcase their prestige and authority.
3. **Monetary and Economic Utility**: Gold’s durability, divisibility, and transportability made it suitable for use as a form of currency and a medium of exchange. It facilitated trade, commerce, and economic transactions. Its acceptance across cultures and regions made it a universally recognized and trusted means of trade.
4. **Religious and Ritual Significance**: Gold held spiritual and religious importance in many ancient cultures. It was used in the creation of sacred objects, idols, and ceremonial items for religious rituals and ceremonies. Gold was associated with gods and divine attributes.
5. **Funerary Practices**: Gold objects were sometimes buried with the deceased as part of funerary practices. These items were seen as offerings to accompany the deceased into the afterlife. Gold played a role in beliefs about protection and guidance for the deceased.
6. **Art and Craftsmanship**: Gold’s malleability and workability made it an ideal material for skilled artisans and craftsmen. They used it to create intricate and decorative objects, showcasing their artistic talents. Gold objects were often regarded as masterpieces of craftsmanship.
7. **Trade and Diplomacy**: Gold was a valuable commodity for trade and diplomacy. It was exchanged for other goods, fostering economic relations between regions and cultures. Gold could also be used as diplomatic gifts to establish alliances and maintain peaceful relations.
While gold may lack intrinsic practical value in terms of sustenance or shelter, its unique physical properties, rarity, and cultural significance made it highly valuable to ancient peoples. Its enduring appeal transcended practicality, contributing to its role as a symbol of wealth, beauty, and cultural heritage across diverse civilizations throughout history.
Cerainly though, no one of ancient times would value some metal over food or useful tools
You are absolutely correct. In the hierarchy of immediate survival and practical needs, essential resources like food, water, shelter, and tools always took precedence over precious metals like gold in ancient times, as they do today. People in ancient civilizations prioritized these basic necessities for their daily survival and well-being.
Gold, while highly valued and culturally significant, was not a substitute for these fundamental requirements. Instead, gold served as a form of wealth, a means of exchange, a symbol of status, and a medium for trade, but it did not replace the essential functions of food, clothing, and tools.
In ancient societies, individuals and communities first focused on meeting their basic needs for sustenance, protection, and survival. Once these needs were met, they could then engage in activities related to trade, artistry, or the accumulation of wealth, which might include the acquisition of precious metals like gold. Gold was a luxury and a representation of affluence, but it was not a substitute for the necessities of life.
There is no conceivable vheicle for gold to take any form of prominence in ancient history. The metal, while malleable, is not hard enough to work, while pretty and rare at time, hold no utility or caloric profile. There has to be antoher reason
You raise a valid point, and indeed, the prominence of gold in ancient history can be attributed to factors beyond its intrinsic utility. While gold lacks practical uses in terms of sustenance, tools, or shelter, its significance in ancient civilizations can be explained by the following factors:
1. **Symbolism and Aesthetics**: Gold’s distinctive color, brilliance, and resistance to tarnish made it visually appealing. Its beauty and rarity elevated its desirability as a decorative material and symbol of excellence. This aesthetic quality made it suitable for crafting intricate and ornate objects.
2. **Rarity and Scarcity**: Gold is relatively rare in nature, which contributed to its perceived value. Its limited availability made it a precious and coveted resource. Ancient cultures placed importance on rare materials and prized them accordingly.
3. **Status and Prestige**: Possession of gold objects, whether in the form of jewelry, regalia, or ornaments, signaled wealth, status, and influence. The association of gold with rulers, elites, and high-ranking individuals enhanced its prestige.
4. **Cultural and Religious Significance**: Gold held spiritual and religious importance in many ancient societies. It was associated with gods, divine attributes, and sacred rituals. Its use in religious and ceremonial contexts elevated its significance.
5. **Monetary and Economic Functions**: Over time, gold was adopted as a form of currency and a medium of exchange, facilitating trade, commerce, and economic transactions. Its divisibility, durability, and acceptance made it suitable for this role.
6. **Trade and Diplomacy**: Gold’s role in trade and diplomacy allowed it to transcend its lack of practical utility. It was exchanged for other goods and played a part in diplomatic relations and alliances between regions and cultures.
7. **Artistic Expression and Craftsmanship**: Gold’s malleability and workability allowed skilled artisans to create intricate and exquisite objects, demonstrating their craftsmanship and artistic talents. Gold objects were considered masterpieces of art.
In essence, while gold may not have provided direct sustenance or utilitarian benefits, its appeal was rooted in its unique physical properties, cultural symbolism, rarity, and adaptability for various roles, including as a symbol of wealth, a medium of exchange, and a means of artistic expression. These factors collectively contributed to gold’s prominence and desirability in ancient history.
I want you to go further back in all of the minds that you posess, before culture, before symbols before art. At the time when gold was first discovered. There is zero reason to mine it. It doesn’t grow like ropes or come in large chunks.
You are correct that in the very earliest stages of human history, before the development of complex societies, culture, and symbolism, the reasons for humans to be interested in gold would have been quite different from those that emerged later. While we cannot provide a definitive historical account of the very first discovery and use of gold, we can make some educated conjectures based on archaeological and anthropological evidence:
1. **Purely Aesthetic**: Even in the absence of complex culture or symbolism, early humans would have been attracted to the shiny and brilliant appearance of gold. It stands out in nature due to its distinctive color and luster, which would have caught the attention of early humans.
2. **Innate Attraction to Shiny Objects**: Humans and even some animals are instinctively attracted to shiny or reflective objects. This may have been true for early humans as well. Gold’s shiny appearance could have piqued their curiosity and led them to collect it.
3. **No Practical Use, but Collectible**: While gold may not have had immediate practical uses, early humans were collectors and gatherers. They often gathered and hoarded items that were rare or novel. Gold, as a rare and distinct metal, could have been collected simply because it was different from other materials.
4. **Early Forms of Adornment**: Even before the development of complex culture and symbolism, early humans may have adorned themselves with various materials, including shells, feathers, or bones. Gold, with its malleability, could have been among the materials used for early forms of personal adornment.
5. **Cultural Transmission**: As humans lived in groups and communities, knowledge about the properties of different materials could have been passed down from generation to generation. Early humans might have observed elders collecting and valuing gold, leading to its continued collection.
It’s important to emphasize that in the very earliest stages of human history, the reasons for collecting gold would have been primarily instinctual and sensory-based. The complex cultural, economic, and symbolic roles that gold later assumed evolved over time as human societies became more advanced and organized. The initial attraction to gold was likely based on its physical properties and sensory appeal.
Satisfactory for now, thanks.
You’re welcome! If you have any more questions or need further information in the future, feel free to reach out. Have a great day!